Original Research

Return on equity: A popular, but flawed measure of corporate financial performance

J. H.V.H. De Wet, E. Du Toit
South African Journal of Business Management | Vol 38, No 1 | a578 | DOI: https://doi.org/10.4102/sajbm.v38i1.578 | © 2018 J. H.V.H. De Wet, E. Du Toit | This work is licensed under CC Attribution 4.0
Submitted: 10 October 2018 | Published: 31 March 2007

About the author(s)

J. H.V.H. De Wet, Department of Financial Management, University of Pretoria, South Africa
E. Du Toit, Department of Financial Management, University of Pretoria, South Africa

Full Text:

PDF (91KB)

Abstract

This article is aimed at analysing the impact of popular financial performance measures on shareholders’ wealth. It tests the strength of the linear relationships between these performance measures and shareholders’ returns, which consist of dividends and changes in the share price. The return on equity (ROE) is weighed up against the present favourite, economic value added (EVA) and the merits and flaws of each approach are discussed. Other approaches, such as a combination of performance measures and the expectations theory are also discussed briefly.
The statistical tests performed found Spreads (a standardised EVA) to be slightly superior to ROE in explaining changes in shareholders’ returns. However, the use of same year data resulted in very weak linear relationships between all the performance measures tested, relative to shareholders’ returns.
When 5-year medians were used in the analysis, significant correlations were obtained between current shareholders’ returns and the future results for the internal performance measures. This engenders some support for the expectations theory with its contention that the most effective positive impact on shareholders’ returns can be accomplished by managing expectations about future financial results, rather than maximising these results now. It is clear that the debate about the effectiveness of traditional accounting performance measures, as well as the search for the real drivers of shareholder value, will continue and increase in intensity.

Keywords

No related keywords in the metadata.

Metrics

Total abstract views: 6072
Total article views: 3850

 

Crossref Citations

1. The value of integrated reporting in South Africa
Maatabudi Mokabane, Elda Du Toit
South African Journal of Economic and Management Sciences  vol: 25  issue: 1  year: 2022  
doi: 10.4102/sajems.v25i1.4305

2. Social expenditure, business responsibility reporting score and firm performance: empirical evidence from India
Chandra Shekhar Bhatnagar, Dyal Bhatnagar, Pritpal Singh Bhullar
Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society  vol: 23  issue: 6  first page: 1404  year: 2023  
doi: 10.1108/CG-04-2022-0173

3. The Effect of ESG on Corporate Performance and the Moderating Role of COVID-19: Evidence from FTSE 350 Companies in the UK
Yuhan Wu, Fafa (Monica) Yan
Review of Economic Assessment  vol: 4  issue: 2  first page: 1  year: 2025  
doi: 10.58567/rea04020001

4. Predictive power of economic-based performance indicators on shareholder value: Evidence from South African listed firms
Dinis P. Maculuve, Adefemi A. Obalade
Investment Management and Financial Innovations  vol: 20  issue: 3  first page: 299  year: 2023  
doi: 10.21511/imfi.20(3).2023.25

5. Cash Flow Management and Assets Growth of Listed Industrial Goods Firms in Nigeria
Osatohanmwen Favour Idehen, Beauty Jackson-Akhigbe, Rachael Abusomwan
FUDMA Journal of Accounting and Finance Research [FUJAFR]  vol: 3  issue: 1  first page: 107  year: 2025  
doi: 10.33003/fujafr-2025.v3i1.150.107-119

6. Financial indicators as determinants of integrated reporting quality: evidence from Poland
Maja Piesiewicz, Paweł Kufel
Meditari Accountancy Research  vol: 33  issue: 3  first page: 929  year: 2025  
doi: 10.1108/MEDAR-04-2024-2455

7. Insight of the Chinese enterprises’ investment performance along ‘one belt one road’
Rui Xue, HuiZheng Liu, Claude Baron, XinYue Miao, Muhammad Afaq Haider Jafri
Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy  vol: 29  issue: 2  first page: 634  year: 2024  
doi: 10.1080/13547860.2022.2035094

8. Role of working capital management in profitability considering the connection between accounting and finance
Amer Morshed
Asian Journal of Accounting Research  vol: 5  issue: 2  first page: 257  year: 2020  
doi: 10.1108/AJAR-04-2020-0023

9. Financial ratios and efficiency in Malaysian listed companies
Ali Saleh Ahmed Alarussi
Asian Journal of Economics and Banking  vol: 5  issue: 2  first page: 116  year: 2021  
doi: 10.1108/AJEB-06-2020-0014

10. Investigating the Explanatory Power of Economic Profits (Evaa) versus Accounting Profits on Stock Returns as a Measure of Shareholders Wealth Creation. An Empirical Study of the FTSE 100.
Moustafa awad El Tamamy
SSRN Electronic Journal  year: 2014  
doi: 10.2139/ssrn.2507191

11. Comprehensive Income: which potential effects on firms' performance evaluation and users' decision process?
Pier Luigi Marchini, Carlotta D'Este
FINANCIAL REPORTING  issue: 2  first page: 55  year: 2016  
doi: 10.3280/FR2015-002003

12. The impact of efficiency and income diversification on performance of commercial banks: evidence from Sub-Saharan African countries
Solomon Terfasa Dinka, Arega Seyoum Asfaw
Cogent Business & Management  vol: 13  issue: 1  year: 2026  
doi: 10.1080/23311975.2025.2597069

13. Does inflation expectation affect banks' performances? Evidence from Indian banking sector
Minnu Baby Maria, Farah Hussain
Journal of Economic and Administrative Sciences  year: 2023  
doi: 10.1108/JEAS-05-2023-0123

14. A review of accounting research in internationalising journals in the South African region
Charl J. De Villiers, Pei-Chi K. Hsiao
South African Journal of Economic and Management Sciences  vol: 20  issue: 1  year: 2017  
doi: 10.4102/sajems.v20i1.1729

15. Job of Working Capital the Board in Productivity Thinking About the Association Among Bookkeeping and Money
Dr. Savita Dwivedi
International Journal of Recent Technology and Engineering (IJRTE)  vol: 10  issue: 6  first page: 1  year: 2022  
doi: 10.35940/ijrte.F6791.0310622

16. European banks’ business models as a driver of strategic planning: one size fits all
Egidio Palmieri, Enrico Fioravante Geretto, Maurizio Polato
Journal of Financial Regulation and Compliance  vol: 31  issue: 1  first page: 16  year: 2023  
doi: 10.1108/JFRC-08-2021-0068

17. Unveiling the nexus: ESG reporting, financial performance, and IPO underpricing in the Indonesian stock market
Muhammad Rahmatullah, Dzikri Firmansyah Hakam
Development and Sustainability in Economics and Finance  vol: 7  first page: 100064  year: 2025  
doi: 10.1016/j.dsef.2025.100064

18. Determinants of Companies’ Financial Performance Following M&A Transactions in Poland
Marcin Ocieszak
Central European Management Journal  vol: 28  issue: 4  first page: 51  year: 2020  
doi: 10.7206/cemj.2658-0845.34

19. Governance Factors Influencing Financial Performance in Cloud-Based Enterprises: A Machine Learning Analysis
Ziling Huang, Lichao Lin, Xiaofei Jia
Computational Economics  vol: 67  issue: 2  first page: 643  year: 2026  
doi: 10.1007/s10614-025-10896-2

20. Impact of board gender diversity on performance of public sector vis-à-vis private sector banks in India
Minnu Baby Maria, Farah Hussain
Gender in Management: An International Journal   vol: 39  issue: 8  first page: 1095  year: 2024  
doi: 10.1108/GM-06-2023-0232

21. Comprehensive Income and Financial Performance Ratios: Which Potential Effects on RoE and on Firm's Performance Evaluation?
Pier Luigi Marchini, Carlotta D’Este
Procedia Economics and Finance  vol: 32  first page: 1724  year: 2015  
doi: 10.1016/S2212-5671(15)01478-1

22. La relación del valor económico agregado (EVA) y el retorno del mercado accionario colombiano 2009 al 2020
Juan Carlos Lezama Palomino, Miguel Ángel Laverde Sarmiento, Jorge Fernando García Carrillo
Revista Facultad de Ciencias Económicas  vol: 31  issue: 1  first page: 53  year: 2023  
doi: 10.18359/rfce.6305

23. ROE (Net Income) versus ROE-CI (Comprehensive Income): A Multidimensional Analysis of a Time-Honoured Performance Metric
Marzena Remlein, Małgorzata Rówińska-Kráľ, Radka MacGregor Pelikánová
Central European Economic Journal  vol: 13  issue: 60  first page: 192  year: 2026  
doi: 10.2478/ceej-2026-0011

24. A European banking business models analysis: the investment services case
Paola Musile Tanzi, Elena Aruanno, Mattia Suardi
Journal of Financial Regulation and Compliance  vol: 26  issue: 1  first page: 35  year: 2018  
doi: 10.1108/JFRC-04-2016-0028

25. Konaklama İşletmelerinde Finansal Performans Ölçütü Olarak Yatırılan Sermayenin Getirisi
Erdinç KARADENİZ, Selda DALAK, Fatih GÜNAY, Mehmet BEYAZGÜL
Anatolia: Turizm Araştırmaları Dergisi  vol: 30  issue: 1  first page: 31  year: 2019  
doi: 10.17123/atad.580628

26. Identifying Key Financial Variables Predicting the Financial Performance of Construction Companies
Wonkyoung Seo, Byungil Kim, Seongdeok Bang, Youngcheol Kang
Journal of Construction Engineering and Management  vol: 150  issue: 3  year: 2024  
doi: 10.1061/JCEMD4.COENG-13959

27. Performance analysis of metaheuristic and risk-averse optimization techniques for portfolio management under volatile markets
Rajat Jaiswal, Namita Srivastava, Manoj Jha, Bayan Albahooth, Thippa Reddy Gadekallu
PeerJ Computer Science  vol: 12  first page: e3499  year: 2026  
doi: 10.7717/peerj-cs.3499

28. El Valor Económico Agregado y su relación con el valor agregado de mercado, la utilidad por acción y el rendimiento de los activos, en México: 2001-2008
María Luisa Saavedra García, Máximo Jorge Saavedra García
Recherches en Sciences de Gestion  vol: N° 90  issue: 3  first page: 15  year: 2012  
doi: 10.3917/resg.090.0017

29. FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE AND SIZE DETERMINANTS: GROWTH TREND AND SIMILARITY ANALYSIS OF INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY
Anis Ali
Humanities & Social Sciences Reviews  vol: 8  issue: 4  first page: 547  year: 2020  
doi: 10.18510/hssr.2020.8454

30. When governments own firms: toward a more nuanced understanding of the influence of state ownership on firm performance
Lill-Beathe Håpnes, Lars Molden, Frode Kjærland
Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society  vol: 26  issue: 1  first page: 21  year: 2026  
doi: 10.1108/CG-10-2022-0409

31. INNOVATION CAPABILITY AND OPEN INNOVATION AND ITS IMPACT ON PERFORMANCE IN SMES: AN EMPIRICAL STUDY IN CHILE
OMAR CARRASCO-CARVAJAL, DOMINGO GARCÍA-PÉREZ-DE-LEMA
International Journal of Innovation Management  vol: 25  issue: 04  first page: 2150039  year: 2021  
doi: 10.1142/S1363919621500390

32. Ownership structure and market efficiency
Masaki Nakabayashi
Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money  vol: 61  first page: 189  year: 2019  
doi: 10.1016/j.intfin.2019.03.003

33. Does EVA Beat ROA and ROE in Explaining the Stock Returns in Indian Scenario? An Evidence Using Mixed Effects Panel Data Regression Model
Ashita Agrawal, Pitabas Mohanty, Navindra Kumar Totala
Management and Labour Studies  vol: 44  issue: 2  first page: 103  year: 2019  
doi: 10.1177/0258042X19832397

34. Compliance with the provisions of the Corporate Governance Code by companies listed on the Romanian capital market with respect to the formation and functioning of audit committees
Marius-Eugen Rogoz, Dragoș-Andrei Stoica
Proceedings of the International Conference on Business Excellence  vol: 15  issue: 1  first page: 737  year: 2021  
doi: 10.2478/picbe-2021-0069

35. Measuring regional business resilience
Anthony Soroka, Gillian Bristow, Mohamed Naim, Laura Purvis
Regional Studies  vol: 54  issue: 6  first page: 838  year: 2020  
doi: 10.1080/00343404.2019.1652893

36. Profitability and marketability efficiency dimensions of banking performance: private versus public banks in India
Minnu Baby Maria, Farah Hussain
Journal of Economic and Administrative Sciences  first page: 1  year: 2026  
doi: 10.1108/JEAS-02-2025-0071

37. Do real estate investment companies profit from house price growth? Evidence from Portugal
António Manuel Cunha, Ana Pinto Borges, Miguel Ferreira
International Journal of Housing Markets and Analysis  vol: 17  issue: 4  first page: 1019  year: 2024  
doi: 10.1108/IJHMA-01-2023-0007

38. El Valor Económico Agregado y su relación con el valor agregado de mercado, la utilidad por acción y el rendimiento de los activos, en México: 2001-2008
María Luisa Saavedra García, Máximo Jorge Saavedra García
Recherches en Sciences de Gestion  vol: N° 90  issue: 3  first page: 15  year: 2012  
doi: 10.3917/s.resg.090.0017

39. Effectiveness, Efficiency and Executive Directors’ Compensation Among Listed Companies in Malaysia
Ali Saleh Ahmed Alarussi
Sage Open  vol: 11  issue: 4  year: 2021  
doi: 10.1177/21582440211054129

40. The Role of Financial Health in Predicting Long-Term Performance in Selected Industries in Thailand
Rey Mom, Sundaresan Mohanlingam, Nguyen Th Phuong Linh, Hiram Reagan Panggabean
HUMAN BEHAVIOR DEVELOPMENT and SOCIETY  first page: 329  year: 2025  
doi: 10.62370/hbds.v26i2.281509